Most local businesses ranking on page one of Google have no links from real local sources at all. A Visilay test of 42 businesses in three Italian cities found their backlink profiles are dominated by spam, with local newspapers and public bodies almost entirely absent.
Visilay checked the backlinks of 42 local businesses ranking on page one of Google in Milan, Bologna and Bari, covering plumbers, dentists, and accountants, on November 11, 2026, using DataForSEO data. The sample is deliberately ordinary: these are not famous brands or national chains, but the kind of small businesses that make up most local search results, and that local SEO advice is written for.
Of 2,808 referring domains classified, 2,480, or 88.3%, were auto-generated or spam sites. Only 17 were real local sources: associations, news sites, events, suppliers, or public bodies. The median site had 68 referring domains, but as Visilay put it, "almost none is a real local link." The typical page-one local business has a backlink profile that looks substantial in a tool and turns out to be almost entirely junk when a human reads it.
The local gap is the striking part. 33 of the 42 sites had not a single link from a local source. Local papers from the same city appeared three times in the whole sample, and public bodies zero times. For businesses whose customers live in one city, the websites that should know them best, the local paper, the council, the trade association, almost never link to them. Whatever is keeping these businesses on page one, it is not local endorsement.
Directories were present on 40 of 42 sites, accounting for 218 domains, or 7.8% of the total, led by small Italian aggregators. Directories are the one category of link that most local businesses reliably have, and they are also the least distinctive: every competitor has the same directory listings, so they cannot be what separates the businesses that rank from the ones that do not.
The study also shows how little local businesses are connected to the web around them, even when they are named. 82% of sites naming Macropix do not link to it, 233 of 284 domains, and 94% for Scovaventi. Local businesses get mentioned without links, and they mention others without linking, which means the local web is far less interconnected than the link data in SEO tools might suggest. Mentions without links are invisible to most link analysis, and in local SEO they appear to be the norm rather than the exception.
Citing Whitespark's Local Search Ranking Factors 2026, based on 47 experts and 187 factors, the study notes that link quality ranks 3rd in local organic results but only 25th to 39th in the local pack. That split helps explain the findings. Links matter for the classic organic results below the map, but the map pack itself, where most local clicks happen, is driven far more by proximity, reviews, and business-profile signals than by who links to whom.
For local link builders, the test is both a warning and an opportunity. The warning is that the standard local link audit is misleading: a profile with 68 referring domains can contain zero links that a human would recognise as an endorsement. Counting domains without classifying them flatters almost every local business and hides the real state of its link profile.
The opportunity is the size of the gap. If 33 out of 42 page-one businesses have no real local link at all, then a single genuine link from a local newspaper, a council page, a trade association, or a local event is a differentiator, not a nice-to-have. These are links competitors do not have, from sources that cannot be bought in bulk, and they are exactly the kind of link that is hardest for a spammy competitor to replicate.
The practical work is unglamorous but straightforward: sponsor a local event, join the trade association, get quoted in the local paper, and make sure the link follows the mention. The businesses in this sample are winning without any of that, which means the bar is low. The first local business in a city that actually builds real local links will be competing against profiles that are 88% spam, and that is a fight worth taking.
Sources: Visilay, November 11, 2026.
Related reading on this site: Google Explains How Redirects Affect Ranking Signals, Fake Googlebots Are Passing Reverse DNS Checks, Log Study Finds, Google: Technical SEO Remains Key for AI SEO, Do Google Updates Still Matter? 14 SEOs Answer, November Search Console Click Spikes Are Bot Traffic, and Google's November 2026 Core Update Is Rolling Out.
Linkbaits helps you create content that earns citations and backlinks. Start with the toolkit and build your first linkable asset this week.
Start free trial