SEO

Do Google Updates Still Matter? 14 SEOs Answer

SEO Growth surveyed 14 SEO experts from Australia, the US and the UK in October 2026, just before Google's November core update landed. Most of them still think Google updates matter — but only a minority have actually seen their traffic or sales fall this year, and the gap between the worry and the numbers is the story.

The headline numbers

Eleven of the 14 SEOs surveyed said Google updates are still important. The other three said they are not. But only 5 of the 13 who answered the question about results said their traffic or sales are down so far in 2026 — just over a third. Three said their results are mixed, two said they have grown or held steady, two are not tracking it, and one said their results are not tied to Google at all. So 79% say updates still matter, but only 38% are seeing a drop. The survey was run by SEO Growth, an Australian agency, and published on November 12, 2026, days after Google started rolling out its November 2026 core update — the third core update of the year. Some figures are out of 13 rather than 14 because respondents did not have to answer every question.

Updates are like the boogeyman

Even the experts who said updates still matter were less worked up about it than the author expected. A lot of the written answers treated updates as something to keep an eye on, not something to lose sleep over. Ashley Urquhart, Head of Content at Firewire Digital, described it well: "Algorithm updates are still important because everyone still talks about them. They are like the boogeyman, always lurking in the background, planting irrational fear in our minds, which manifests when we see slight dips in graphs on Looker." The quote captures the mood of the panel: updates still move rankings and impressions, but after years of constant core and spam updates, many SEOs have learned to watch the data rather than panic at the announcement.

AI Mode is the bigger story

Where the panel sees the bigger change is AI Mode and AI Overviews, which are changing how people search and where the clicks go. One Head of SEO on the panel said that while rankings improved across the year, there were keywords where the site was still in position one but an AI Overview appearing on top wiped out the traffic. Informational keywords are being eaten up by AI answers in particular. The point is blunt: you can hold your rankings through every update and still lose traffic, because Google now answers the question above the results. Updates still cause short-term movement, but AI Mode is changing where clicks go — and that is what business owners should be planning for, according to the survey's author.

Update fatigue is real

There have been four spam updates and three core updates in 2026 so far, and some SEOs are simply tuning them out. One panel member said the market has become uneasy after three or four years of constant updates, and another said Google keeps moving the goalposts — first treating auto-generated content as spam, then saying AI content is fine if it is helpful, and now telling sites to fact-check every AI page before it goes live. Zak Ali, founder of Creative Advisor, put it bluntly: the value exchange between Google and creators is so lopsided that people no longer feel incentivised to listen to or care about following Google's web standards. Thirteen of the 14 SEOs said they saw this update coming, and 8 of the 14 think there will be at least one more spam update before the end of 2026.

Why it matters for SEOs and link builders

The survey's advice for the November rollout is to expect movement and not to react to every swing. Google says the rollout can take up to two weeks, and rankings could keep moving during one of the busiest sales periods of the year, with Black Friday and Christmas coming up. Big changes made mid-rollout can make things worse, so the sensible move is to wait until the update finishes, then compare traffic and leads against before it started. The longer lesson is to plan for AI Mode as well as for updates: check whether AI Overviews show up for the searches that matter to you, and whether your business gets mentioned in them. Links from trusted, relevant sites still help a page rank and still help it get cited, so the work that survives both updates and AI answers is the same work it always was — genuinely useful content, backed by real links.

Sources

Sources: SEO Growth, November 12, 2026.

Related reading on this site: Google's November 2026 Core Update Is Rolling Out, SEO Split Testing in 2027: How to Prove a Change Actually Worked, Google Rank Data Issues, Lighthouse Update and AI Opt-Out, Google Explains How Redirects Affect Ranking Signals, Google: Technical SEO Remains Key for AI SEO, and AI Overviews Appear on 70% of Everyday UK Searches, Sayu Study Finds.

More from Linkbaits

Turn this playbook into links

Linkbaits helps you create content that earns citations and backlinks. Start with the toolkit and build your first linkable asset this week.

Start free trial