SEO

The Traffic Pool Is Shrinking — and That Changes Everything

The SEO industry spent late October arguing about a ratio: how much traffic AI assistants send compared with Google organic search. Duane Forrester, the former Bing webmaster lead who now runs consultancy UnboundAnswers.com, says the debate misses the number underneath it. The pool of search visits both channels draw from is getting smaller, and which channel fills it matters less than we think.

Three studies, one misleading conclusion

Forrester starts with the three pieces of research that landed within days of each other and carried the whole conversation. Marie Haynes looked at 12 months of GA4 data across 100 sites and more than 145 million sessions, and found that ChatGPT sent 0.62% of the sessions Google organic did, rising to 0.73% with every large language model included. The SEO Works benchmarked 95 sites and found organic search delivered 39 times the traffic of AI assistants. Kevin Indig ran 632 tests across 12 sites looking for AI visibility to show up later as branded search or direct traffic, and could not find a reliable relationship. The conclusion the wider industry drew from them travelled faster than the work itself, Forrester argues: AI sends almost nothing, so the new field of generative engine optimisation is a distraction, so get back to Google. That reading answers a reasonable question, which channel sends more visitors today, and the answer is plainly Google.

The pool is draining, not moving

Forrester points to evidence published by Indig a few days later as the clearest picture of what is happening. In an analysis of 10,000 domains in each of the United States and France using Similarweb data, organic search visits fell 13.2% in the US and 24.4% in France between August 2024 and August 2026, and publishers lost roughly 41.5% of their organic traffic in the US over the same two years. Paid search visits grew in the same data, and Alphabet's third-quarter filing shows paid clicks still up 8% year over year, so the open web is losing visits from search while Google's own paid inventory keeps growing. Indig notes that paid growth replaced only about a third of the organic visits lost in the US, and that AI referrals, the fastest-growing channel in his sample, still account for about one visit in 200. Nothing on the search side of that picture refills the pool.

Where businesses are rebuilding instead

Forrester's follow-up points to where some businesses are rebuilding the pool instead of fighting over what is left of it. In Indig's data, email grew about 16% in the US sample, the steadiest gain of any channel, because it reaches an audience a business already owns. That is the heart of Forrester's argument: the question that matters is not where traffic comes from today, which is a dashboard question and backward-looking, but what happens to a business when discovery shifts from clicks to answers. For traffic-dependent businesses, Forrester writes, the visit was only a step toward the sale. Agents now finish that job, and the work starts with the offer. In other words, when an AI agent can complete a purchase or book a service on a customer's behalf, the business that wins is the one whose offer the agent can find, understand and act on, not the one that ranked first for a keyword.

Being indexed no longer means being visited

The same logic runs through Forrester's companion piece on indexing, which makes the mechanism behind the shrinking pool concrete. Being indexed used to buy a visit: a crawler took your pages, the search engine sent people back, and ranking decided how close to eye level you sat. Once the answer layer becomes the default, Forrester argues, being indexed buys only eligibility, the right to be considered when a system assembles an answer, with no promise that anyone arrives at your site. The evidence he cites points the same way. In Pew Research Center's browsing analysis, users clicked a traditional result in 8% of visits when an AI summary appeared, against 15% when one did not. A preregistered field experiment by researchers at Penn and Northeastern found that routing every search into AI Mode for a week cut click-through to external sites by 18.8 percentage points compared with normal Google Search. Forrester puts the window for the ranked results page to stop being Google's default first response at 2028 to 2030, with the links one click away rather than gone.

Why it matters for SEOs and link builders

Forrester's argument reframes the job rather than ending it. If the traffic pool is shrinking, fighting harder for a bigger share of a smaller pool is a losing strategy, and the work shifts to three things. First, being selected into the answer becomes the end goal, which means content must be quotable, factual and structured so an AI system can draw on it with confidence. Second, the offer matters more than the visit: a business needs clear pricing, availability and a path to purchase that an agent can complete. Third, owned audiences become the insurance policy, since email grew about 16% while search visits fell, and an audience you own cannot be taken away by a change in how a search engine presents results.

Sources

Sources: Search Engine Journal, November 12, 2026.

Related reading on this site: ChatGPT Sends Just 0.62% of Google's Organic Traffic, Google's Search Volume Is About 5x ChatGPT's, OpenAI Says, AI Overviews Appear on 70% of Everyday UK Searches, Sayu Study Finds, SEO Split Testing in 2027: How to Prove a Change Actually Worked, Google Explains How Redirects Affect Ranking Signals, and Google: Technical SEO Remains Key for AI SEO.

More from Linkbaits

Turn this playbook into links

Linkbaits helps you create content that earns citations and backlinks. Start with the toolkit and build your first linkable asset this week.

Start free trial