Most local businesses ranking on page one of Google have never earned a single link from a real local source. Visilay checked the backlinks of 42 local businesses on page one in Milan, Bologna and Bari on November 11, 2026, and found that 33 of them had not one link from a trade association, chamber of commerce, local newspaper, supplier, event or public body. Of the 2,808 referring domains classified, only 17 were real local sources, and 88% were auto-generated or spam sites.
Visilay pulled Google's first page for plumbers, dentists and accountants in the three Italian cities, kept only the websites of single businesses, and dropped portals, directories and multi-city networks. That left 42 sites. For each one, the team downloaded up to 100 referring domains from DataForSEO's backlink index and classified them by domain name, erring on the side of caution when a domain was ambiguous.
The median site had 68 referring domains, so these are not linkless websites. They have links, just not local ones. Only 2 of the 42 sites had links from more than one kind of local source. The local link, the thing local SEO guides have recommended for a decade, is almost entirely absent from the businesses that actually rank.
The bulk of the link profiles is noise. Auto-generated or spam sites accounted for 2,480 of the 2,808 referring domains, or 88.3%, and every one of the 42 sites had at least one. These are the domains that appear in almost every small business backlink profile: scrapers, auto-generated directories, and spam networks that link to everything. They are not earned, not local, and not useful, but they dominate the count.
The mentions tell a second story. Visilay measured two companies it works with and found that 82% of the sites naming Macropix do not link to it, 233 domains out of 284, and for Scovaventi the share is 94%. Local businesses are talked about far more often than they are linked to, which matches the wider pattern in AI search: mentions and links mostly capture different coverage, and a brand can be visible in one without the other.
The obvious question is how these businesses rank on page one with almost no local links, and the answer is in Whitespark's Local Search Ranking Factors 2026, an expert survey of 187 factors published on November 6, 2025. In local organic results, link factors rank 3rd, 5th and 13th, but in the local pack they drop to between 25th and 39th. Proximity, the primary business category, keywords in the business name, and being open when the search is made matter more for the map than links do.
That split explains the test results. These businesses rank because they are close to the searcher, categorised correctly, and open, not because they have local links. It also explains why the local link gap is an opportunity rather than a verdict: if almost nobody in a market has real local links, the first business that earns a handful of them has a differentiator its competitors do not. The test shows a market where the bar is on the floor.
For local SEOs, the test is a useful reality check on where to spend effort. Chasing generic backlinks for a local business is mostly adding to the 88% noise. The work that moves the needle is narrower and more concrete: a link from the local chamber, a mention in the local paper, a supplier page, a sponsorship of a local team or event. Visilay lists eight such sources, easiest first, and the test suggests that even one or two of them would put a business ahead of most of its page-one competitors.
For link builders, the test reframes local link building as an open field rather than a crowded one. The 33-of-42 figure means the competition for real local links is almost non-existent in these markets, and the same is likely true in many others. A local business that earns a genuine link from its community is not catching up, it is lapping the field. The pitch to a local client should lead with that number, because it makes the opportunity tangible in a way that a generic link-building promise does not.
The test is small, Italian, and limited to three trades, so it should not be read as a global census. The pattern is worth testing elsewhere, though: pick a city and a trade, pull the page-one businesses, and count their real local links. If the same gap shows up, local link building is the cheapest competitive advantage in that market. And as AI answers start naming local businesses, the sources that cite them will matter more, which makes a real local link worth more than the spam domains that currently fill most profiles.
Sources: Visilay, November 11, 2026.
Related reading on this site: November Core Update Collides With Black Friday, and a Clean Read Will Not Come Until December, Core Update Volatility Started Days Before Google Announced It, November Search Console Click Spikes May Be Bots, SEJ Reports, SEJ Pulse: Core Update, ChatGPT Business Hub and AI Mode's New Model, AI Overview Citations: What 15 Studies Agree On, and Don't, and Black Friday SEO Starts Eight Weeks Out, and November Is Already Late.
Linkbaits helps you create content that earns citations and backlinks. Start with the toolkit and build your first linkable asset this week.
Start free trial