Google has restated one of the oldest rules in technical SEO — and cleared up a confusion that still trips up site migrations. In a discussion between Google's Gary Illyes and Cherry Prommawin, reported by Search Engine Journal on November 5, 2026, Illyes explained that a 301 permanent redirect passes ranking signals from the old URL to the new one, while a 302 temporary redirect does not. Both types still help Google group similar pages together, but only the 301 tells Google which URL should be the canonical one. For anyone planning a site move or a URL cleanup, the distinction is the difference between keeping your rankings and quietly losing them.
The core of the explanation is simple. A 301 redirect tells Google's crawlers that a change of URL is permanent and that the search index should be updated with the new URL. A 302 tells the crawler the change is temporary and that the old URL will eventually be restored. Prommawin noted that regardless of redirect type, a page is still going to be indexed — the crawlers, in her words, "don't care at all." What changes is which URL Google shows, and where the ranking signals end up.
With a 301, Illyes said, Google takes all the ranking signals of the old page and hands them to the new page, which then becomes the canonical URL. With a 302, Google assumes you are going back eventually, keeps the old URL in the search results, and basically ignores the new one. The practical consequence is stark: a site that migrates to new URLs using 302s instead of 301s can watch its new pages fail to inherit the authority its old pages spent years earning, while the old URLs linger in the results pointing at content that has moved.
First comes clustering, or deduplication: Google groups pages with similar main content into a cluster, so it does not rank several near-identical pages for the same query. Both 301 and 302 redirects have an effect on clustering — they help Google see that two URLs belong to the same group. But only the 301 has a canonicalization effect, which is the final step, where Google selects one official URL to represent the entire cluster in search results.
That distinction matters for content cannibalization: when several similar pages compete for the same query, cluster them, choose one representative, and let the signals transfer to it. A 301 is the strongest tool for that job, because it both clusters and canonicalizes. Google's own documentation ranks redirects as the strongest canonical signal, ahead of rel="canonical", with sitemap inclusion as a weak signal. Even with a correct 301, Google says it may sometimes still show the old URL as an alternate name for the canonical — but the ranking signals still move.
The discussion also covered the modern equivalents: 307 is the modern version of the 302, and 308 is the modern version of the 301. The key difference from their older counterparts is that they preserve submitted POST data, such as form data, during the redirect. The same rules apply — 308 is permanent and passes signals, 307 is temporary and does not. Google recommends server-side redirects like 301s and 302s rather than the older meta refresh or JavaScript redirects, which are slower, need the browser to do more work, and may never be seen at all if rendering fails. JavaScript redirects, Google says, are a last resort.
That advice has a direct operational meaning for migrations. Google's site-move guide says to keep redirects in place for at least a year, so Google can transfer signals and recrawl links from other sites, and its Change of Address guidance sets a minimum of 180 days. Redirecting many old pages to the new home page can be treated as a soft 404, so each URL should be mapped to its closest equivalent or returned as a 404 or 410.
For SEOs, the November 5 clarification is a useful audit trigger. Check your live redirects now: a 302 that should be a 301 is a silent leak, and it is the kind of mistake that survives for years because the page still loads and the traffic still arrives — just to the wrong URL, with the signals split. Check the redirects left behind by past redesigns, CMS migrations, and domain moves, and check whether your canonical tags agree with your redirect targets. If they disagree, Google is being given two different answers, and it will pick one of them.
For link builders, redirects are where earned links live or die. A backlink pointing at a URL that 301-redirects to the live page still passes its value; a backlink pointing at a URL that 302-redirects to a page Google ignores is a link that does not count the way you think it does. When you audit a site's link profile, or when you inherit links after a client migration, verify the redirect type on every linked URL that moved. The links you earned are only as strong as the redirect that carries them, and a 302 where a 301 belongs is a link quietly going to waste.
Sources: Search Engine Journal, November 5, 2026.
Related reading on this site: Google Organic Click Share Hits a 15-Month High as Zero-Click Searches Fall, AI Traffic Is Growing 45% a Year — but Still Just 1.25 Visits per 100 From Google, Google Rewrites Its 'Crawled – Currently Not Indexed' Guidance, SEO Pulse: Rank Data Throttled, Lighthouse 13.6 Moves PageSpeed Scores, Only 3.7% of 15,389 Bought Backlinks Were in Google's Index a Year Later, and Why Backlinks Alone Won't Save Big Brands in AI Search.
Linkbaits helps you create content that earns citations and backlinks. Start with the toolkit and build your first linkable asset this week.
Start free trial