Google is moving on two fronts at once: building the search opt-out the UK's Competition and Markets Authority has mandated, while upgrading AI Overviews in ways that could make opting out less appealing. That is the picture in Digiday's reporting from November 9. The opt-out is a Search Console control that lets publishers exclude their content from Google's AI features. The click data publishers need to judge the trade-off is due to UK publishers by December 3, and page-level grounding controls are due by March 3, 2027. The controls are bundled — publishers cannot opt out of individual features — which is why most of them are waiting.
The opt-out follows the CMA's first conduct requirement on Google, imposed over the summer. Although the ruling applied only to the UK, Google opened the control to sites worldwide on August 31. It is a Search Console control that lets a publisher exclude its content from Google's AI features, including AI Overviews and AI Mode. Page-level grounding controls — the ability to apply the exclusion to individual pages rather than whole directories or properties — are due by March 3, 2027.
The key limitation is that the controls are bundled. A publisher cannot opt out of AI Overviews while staying in AI Mode, or opt out of one feature while keeping another. That leaves publishers weighing the potential visibility of being inside AI answers against the loss of control over how their content is used, and waiting for click data to help judge the trade-off. The Professional Publishers Association is appealing to the CMA to press Google to unbundle the controls so they apply to individual features, rather than solely at site and page level.
Google has shown regulators and publishers that it is cooperating by sharing impression data: how often publisher content appears in AI features. But it has held back the click data, which would show whether those appearances actually send people to publishers' sites. That click data is the missing piece of the puzzle, and it is what the December 3 deadline is about.
Publishers told Digiday they are holding off on testing the bundled Search Console control until Google hands over the click data. Chris Dicker, CEO of Candr Media, which owns Trusted Reviews, said everyone is holding off on experimenting with the controls, and expects Google to share the click data in the coming weeks, ahead of Black Friday — when publishers are unlikely to risk experimenting with opt-outs during a crucial sales period.
The click data Google is required to provide to UK publishers by December 3 will give them a key missing piece: impressions, clicks and click-through rate for AI search features, aggregated across AI Overviews and AI Mode. Given that Google made the first requirements global, publishers hope it will provide the click data globally too. Google has not confirmed that it will. Reuters Digital's Phil Andraos told Digiday in June that the lack of click data meant any decision could be slow and would probably involve testing — a prediction that has held up.
The waiting is rational. Opting out removes a publisher's content from AI features, but it also removes the visibility that comes with being cited. Without click data, a publisher cannot tell whether the citations are sending readers or just lending their content to answers that keep readers on Google. The December 3 data will let them measure AI feature clicks against organic clicks, and then decide page by page.
While publishers wait, Google has been making AI Overviews more attractive to stay in. Digiday reports that Google has updated AI Mode and AI Overviews to show links more often and more prominently, added timely article carousels, and included links to related stories and more context around surfaced articles. The message to publishers is that the AI features are becoming a better shop window for their content, even as the opt-out gives them the right to leave it.
There is a catch that publishers are watching closely. Some publishers expect excluded sites to drop out of the Top Stories carousel Google now places inside AI Overviews, and Google has not said how its control treats that unit. A publisher that opts out of AI features to protect its content could find it has also opted out of a prominent news surface — a cost that is hard to weigh without the click data that shows what the carousel is worth.
For SEOs and link builders, the December 3 deadline is the date that matters most. Until the click data arrives, any advice about opting out is guesswork. Once it lands, the work becomes measurement: export the AI feature metrics, compare AI clicks with organic clicks for the same pages, and decide where the trade-off favours staying in. The publishers that will do best are the ones that treat the opt-out as a page-level tool once the March 2027 controls arrive — keeping high-value pages in the features where citations convert, and pulling pages where the answer takes the click and gives nothing back.
Sources: Digiday, November 9, 2026.
Related reading on this site: Google Organic Click Share Hits a 15-Month High as Zero-Click Searches Fall, 83% of ChatGPT Shopping Picks Also Rank in Google's Top 40, Semrush Finds, Search Console's Device Filter Is Now Multi-Select, AI Traffic Is Growing 45% a Year — but Still Just 1.25 Visits per 100 From Google, Only 3.7% of 15,389 Bought Backlinks Were in Google's Index a Year Later, and Ahrefs Previews Domain Rating 4: Half of Sites Lose DR on December 1.
Linkbaits helps you create content that earns citations and backlinks. Start with the toolkit and build your first linkable asset this week.
Start free trial