AI Search

Google's AI Features Sent One Site an Estimated 21% of Its Clicks

How many clicks do Google's AI features actually send? One SEO decided to find out by turning them off. Cyrus Shepard, founder of Zyppy SEO, excluded his own site from Google's AI features using Search Console's Search generative AI control on September 1, opted back in on September 29, and compared the two 28-day periods. His estimate: AI Overviews and AI Mode accounted for about 21% of the site's Google search clicks. Add a small lift in regular-listing clicks that he attributes to AI visibility, and he puts the share of search clicks tied to AI features at 23%. The results were published in his newsletter on Thursday, and reported by Search Engine Journal on November 9.

How the estimate was built

Shepard's method was simple in design and honest about its limits. In less than an hour of opting out, he said, Zyppy's website disappeared from the AI features on Google. He then compared the total clicks the site generated during the 28 days it was opted out with the total clicks generated during the next 28 days once it was opted back in. The difference, after accounting for the site's baseline, is his estimate of the clicks the AI features were producing.

The arithmetic behind the headline number runs through click-through rate. Google counts clicks on an AI Overview or AI Mode link as a standard click within Search Console's Performance report, so the opted-in period's extra clicks can be compared with the AI impressions the site received. Shepard's comparison came to an estimated click-through rate of about 0.9% for Zyppy's AI Overview and AI Mode impressions, and he considers 0.7% to 1.1% a reasonable range. With AI features making up about 10% of the site's search impressions and drawing clicks at that higher rate, he estimates they produced about 21% of its search clicks.

Shepard also noticed a second effect. When the site was back inside the AI features, clicks on its regular organic listings rose slightly as well, which he attributes to the extra visibility that comes from appearing in AI answers. Adding that lift takes the total share of search clicks tied to AI features to an estimated 23%. That is a judgment call layered on top of an estimate, and Shepard presents it as such rather than as a measured fact.

The caveats matter as much as the number

Shepard is explicit that this is a single experiment on a single site, and he wrote that readers should treat the findings more as a directional yardstick than Google gospel, and not assume the numbers apply to other sites. Zyppy is a small, well-known SEO site whose pages are unusually likely to be cited in AI answers about SEO topics. A news publisher, an ecommerce store or a local business could see a very different share, in either direction.

The experiment also exposes a measurement gap that Google itself has not closed. The Search Console generative AI report shows impressions only — no clicks, no click-through rate, no queries — which is exactly why Shepard had to estimate the clicks at all. That gap is now on a deadline: the UK's Competition and Markets Authority gives Google until December 3 to provide publishers with impressions, clicks and click-through rate for AI search features, aggregated across AI Overviews and AI Mode. Until that data exists, opt-out experiments like Shepard's are the only way site owners can put a number on AI clicks.

Why it matters for SEOs and link builders

The 21% figure cuts against the simplest version of the AI-search story, in which AI answers only take clicks away. For this site, at least, the AI features were a meaningful source of clicks in their own right — roughly one in five. That does not cancel out the traffic publishers have lost to AI answers, and Ziff Davis's numbers from the same week show the other side of the ledger. But it does mean the choice is not simply visibility versus traffic. For sites that get cited, AI features can be both a visibility channel and a click channel at once.

For link builders, the implication is to treat AI citation as a traffic discipline, not just a branding exercise. Pages that are cited in AI Overviews and AI Mode can earn clicks from those citations, and the click-through rate Shepard estimated — around 0.9% of AI impressions — is a starting benchmark for what a cited page might expect. The work that earns citations is familiar: clear, quotable answers, strong topical authority, and the backlinks that signal a page is worth trusting. The difference is that the payoff now shows up partly inside Google's AI answers, where the click is harder to measure but, as this experiment suggests, very real.

Sources

Sources: Search Engine Journal, November 9, 2026, reporting Cyrus Shepard's Zyppy SEO opt-out experiment.

Related reading on this site: Google Organic Click Share Hits a 15-Month High as Zero-Click Searches Fall, 83% of ChatGPT Shopping Picks Also Rank in Google's Top 40, Semrush Finds, Search Console's Device Filter Is Now Multi-Select, AI Traffic Is Growing 45% a Year — but Still Just 1.25 Visits per 100 From Google, Only 3.7% of 15,389 Bought Backlinks Were in Google's Index a Year Later, and Ahrefs Previews Domain Rating 4: Half of Sites Lose DR on December 1.

More from Linkbaits

Turn this playbook into links

Linkbaits helps you create content that earns citations and backlinks. Start with the toolkit and build your first linkable asset this week.

Start free trial