Google's €1.49 billion AdSense fine may be revived, after an adviser to the EU's top court said the lower court was wrong to annul it. The opinion is non-binding, but the court usually follows such recommendations, and a final ruling is expected in 2027.
Advocate General Juliane Kokott told the Court of Justice of the EU on November 12, 2026 that the General Court was wrong to annul the European Commission's €1.49 billion ($1.7 billion) AdSense fine, in case C-826/24 P, Commission v Google and Alphabet. The opinion goes to the heart of the case: whether the Commission proved its claim that Google used restrictive AdSense contracts to shut rival search ads out of publisher websites.
The General Court annulled the fine on September 18, 2024, faulting the Commission's analysis of contract duration. Kokott said the lower court imposed excessive requirements on that point, effectively demanding more proof than the law requires. If the Court of Justice agrees, the annulment falls and the fine comes back into play, though the final decision rests with the judges, not the advocate general.
Kokott also proposed the fine should be reduced in any event, because the General Court's finding of no demonstrated exclusionary effects in 2016 was never appealed. That is an important qualification: even in the best outcome for the Commission, the amount may come down. The adviser is saying the fine should stand in principle, but that the Commission cannot have the full sum when part of the case against it was never challenged.
The Commission imposed the fine in March 2019 over restrictive clauses in AdSense for Search contracts that blocked rival search ads on publisher sites. The practices ran from 2006 to 2016, and Google removed the clauses in 2016. The conduct at issue is therefore old, and the clauses are long gone, but the case has been working its way through the courts for more than seven years, and the money at stake is still very real.
The AdSense fine was one of six EU antitrust penalties that have cost Google €10.38 billion over nearly two decades. That total makes the AdSense case part of a much larger story about how Europe has tried to police Google's dominance in search and advertising, through fines that are individually huge and collectively among the largest antitrust penalties ever imposed on a single company.
The long timeline is itself part of the story. A fine imposed in 2019, for conduct that ended in 2016, annulled in 2024, and possibly revived in 2027, shows how slowly competition law moves relative to the markets it regulates. By the time the Court of Justice rules, the search advertising market will have changed again, with AI answers and chatbots reshaping how ads reach users.
The opinion is non-binding, but the Court of Justice usually follows most such recommendations, so the odds favour revival of the fine in some form. A final ruling is expected in 2027. Until then, Google and the Commission will both be preparing for the possibility that the €1.49 billion comes back, possibly reduced, and for the precedent the ruling sets on how much proof the Commission needs to show about contract duration in abuse-of-dominance cases.
For publishers, the case is a reminder of how the AdSense market was shaped. The clauses at issue restricted which rival search ads could appear on publisher sites, which limited publishers' ability to shop around for the best-paying ads. The clauses are gone, but the case matters because it defines what a dominant platform can and cannot demand from the publishers who depend on it, and that question is as live now as it was in 2006.
For SEOs and link builders, the direct impact is limited: this is a competition case about advertising contracts, not about rankings or links. But the broader signal matters. Regulators in Europe are still willing to pursue Google over conduct from a decade ago, and the penalties still run into the billions. Anyone building a business that depends on Google's platforms should expect that scrutiny to continue, and should not assume that old practices are forgotten just because they ended years ago.
Sources: Reuters via PYMNTS, November 12, 2026.
Related reading on this site: EU Finds TikTok's For You Feed in Breach of the DSA, Google Ads Adds an Invalid Traffic Card Showing Your Refunds, Google Ads Bans AI Impersonation of Public Figures, Even If Disclosed, Meta Explains How Its 'Your Algorithm' Ranks What You See, Microsoft Advertising Rolls Out Interface Updates, and Google Ads API and Editor Get November Updates.
Linkbaits helps you create content that earns citations and backlinks. Start with the toolkit and build your first linkable asset this week.
Start free trial