Sometimes the best new shopping destination is a page you already have. That is the starting point for Toby Brissett's piece in Search Engine Land on when an ecommerce site genuinely needs a new category page. The answer is not always to build: often the right move is to improve what exists, and to create a new page only where a real gap remains.
The piece argues that the first question should be whether an existing page can serve the need. A category page that already ranks, already earns links and already guides shoppers is an asset, and a new page created alongside it can split that strength rather than add to it. Before building, it is worth asking whether the existing page can be expanded, reorganised or given better content to cover the demand.
That discipline matters because every new URL is a commitment. It needs to be crawled, indexed, linked to, maintained and kept up to date as the catalogue changes. A page created on a hunch and then neglected can become a weak spot in the site, competing with stronger pages for the same queries and confusing both shoppers and search engines about which page should rank.
The decision framework in the piece centres on spotting gaps worth filling. A gap is a group of products, or a way of shopping, that no existing page serves well: shoppers looking for it find nothing useful, or they land on a page that covers it only in passing. When that gap is real and the demand behind it is genuine, a new category page can give those shoppers a clear destination and give search engines a clear page to rank.
The test is whether the new page would serve a distinct purpose. If it would simply repeat what another page already does, it is not filling a gap; it is duplicating one. The useful question is what a shopper would do differently on the new page, and whether the products grouped there belong together in a way that helps someone choose. If the answer is unclear, the gap probably is not worth filling yet.
The other half of the framework is restraint: avoid creating unnecessary URLs. Each extra category page adds to the site's architecture, and a sprawling architecture makes it harder for shoppers to navigate and harder for search engines to understand which pages matter most. Thin or near-duplicate category pages can also dilute the signals that help the strongest pages rank.
Restraint is not the same as standing still. It means treating a new category page as a decision with costs as well as benefits, and making it only when the case is clear. A site that adds pages thoughtfully, with a distinct purpose for each one, is easier to manage and easier to shop than a site that has grown by adding a page for every passing idea.
For SEOs, the piece is a reminder that site architecture is a ranking factor in practice, even when it is not named as one. A clear set of category pages, each with a distinct purpose and a real set of products behind it, helps search engines understand the site and helps shoppers find what they need. The work is in the decisions about what to build and what to improve, not in the volume of pages created.
For link builders, the lesson is that links work best when they point to pages that deserve them. A new category page that fills a genuine gap is a page worth linking to, because it serves a real shopping need and can earn its place in results. A page created without a purpose is harder to promote and harder to justify. The strongest link-building asset is a page that shoppers and search engines both find useful, and that starts with the decision to build it for a reason.
Sources: Search Engine Land, November 6, 2026, by Toby Brissett, on when an ecommerce site needs a new category page.
Related reading on this site: Google Shopping Still Dominates EU Product Results After the DMA Changes, 83% of ChatGPT Shopping Picks Also Rank in Google's Top 40, Semrush Finds, Google Brings Direct Checkout in AI Mode to Canada, Google Merchant Center Went Down on November 6 — and Google Confirmed It, Google Merchant Center Will Require 500×500 Product Images From January 31, 2027, and Product Feeds Are Becoming the New Ad Creative in Google AI Mode.
Linkbaits helps you create content that earns citations and backlinks. Start with the toolkit and build your first linkable asset this week.
Start free trial