One of the most consequential AI agent cases in American law returns to court on November 20, 2026. Amazon's lawsuit against Perplexity, over whether its Comet browser agent may shop on Amazon on a customer's behalf, has already produced a preliminary injunction, an appeals court reversal and a fresh complaint aimed at Comet for iOS. The question at the centre of it all is simple to state and hard to answer: when an AI agent acts, is it the user acting, or is it someone else?
Amazon sued Perplexity in November 2025 under the US Computer Fraud and Abuse Act and California's Comprehensive Computer Data Access and Fraud Act. The allegation was that Comet, Perplexity's browser agent, entered customer Amazon accounts without permission while disguised as an ordinary Chrome browser. In Amazon's telling, the agent was not a customer at all — it was an unauthorised visitor pretending to be one, and its purchases were access without authorisation under federal and state computer crime law.
The stakes were obvious. If an AI agent can log into a site and buy things while presenting itself as a normal browser, every website's terms of service faces the same question: does the agent count as the user, or as a third party? Amazon's answer was that it counts as a third party, and that the disguise — sending Chrome's user-agent instead of identifying as an agent — proved the point.
In March 2026, a federal district judge agreed with Amazon and blocked the agent, issuing a preliminary injunction on March 9, 2026. For a few months, that looked like the shape of the law: agents that enter accounts without the site's permission are unauthorised, whatever the user asked them to do. It was a win for the idea that websites can set the terms on which automated visitors arrive.
Then, on August 4, 2026, the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit vacated the injunction. The appeals court held that Comet only acts on a user's instructions, so the agent is an extension of the user rather than an independent intruder. On that reading, a customer who tells Comet to buy something on Amazon is doing the same thing as a customer who clicks buy themselves — the agent is a tool, not a trespasser. Amazon asked the court to rehear the case, and the court refused on September 10, 2026.
Eleven days after the rehearing refusal, Amazon filed an amended complaint aimed at a different target: Comet for iOS. The new allegation is that the iOS app copied users' Amazon session cookies to Perplexity's cloud, where a headless browser did the shopping. Amazon says this ran from the app's launch in March 2026 until Perplexity disabled the feature in May. The shift matters because it moves the argument from the browser to the cloud: the shopping happened on Perplexity's servers, using the user's credentials, not on the user's device.
Amazon also alleges that Perplexity induced customers to breach Amazon's terms by sending Chrome's user-agent instead of identifying as an agent, across roughly 185,000 sessions. That number gives the case a scale that the original browser complaint lacked. It is no longer a question about a single agent's behaviour in principle — it is a claim about a large volume of sessions in which, Amazon says, the agent systematically presented itself as something it was not.
Perplexity moved to dismiss the amended complaint in mid-October, and the matter returns to court on November 20, 2026. The hearing will test whether the new complaint survives the Ninth Circuit's August ruling. If an agent acting on instructions is the user, Amazon needs the iOS facts — the cloud copying of session cookies, the headless browser, the 185,000 sessions — to amount to something different in kind, not just in scale.
Nothing about the November 20 date decides the case. A dismissal motion is a threshold question: even if Amazon's facts are taken as true, do they state a legal claim? But the hearing will set the terms for everything that follows. If the amended complaint survives, the case proceeds to discovery on the iOS facts. If it is dismissed, Amazon will have to decide whether to appeal, amend again, or accept the Ninth Circuit's framing of agents as users.
For SEOs, the case is a preview of the legal framework that will govern AI agents as search and shopping intermediaries. If agents are legally the user, then the traffic they generate, the pages they fetch and the links they follow are user traffic — and publishers, search engines and retailers will have to treat them that way. If agents are third parties, then sites can block them, sue them and set terms for them, and the agent economy will need permission at every step.
For link builders, the practical lesson is about attribution and access. An agent that shops, researches and cites on a user's behalf still needs sources to cite, and the sites it trusts will be the ones it returns to. But if the law treats agents as trespassers, the agent layer may be fenced off from large parts of the web — and the content that gets cited will be the content on sites that welcome agents in. The November 20 hearing is one more step toward finding out which world we are in.
Sources: Medium (Leif Gamertsfelder), November 8, 2026.
Related reading on this site: Google, Amazon, Microsoft and Meta Could Dominate AI Agents, Open Markets Warns, Anthropic Reportedly Moving Ahead With IPO Plans, Brave Sells Its Search Index to AI — and the New York Times Is Suing, Penske and Chegg Appeal Dismissal of AI Overviews Antitrust Claims, 88% Disconnect Between Google Top 10 and ChatGPT Recommendations, Study Finds, and Google Brings Direct Checkout in AI Mode to Canada.
Linkbaits helps you create content that earns citations and backlinks. Start with the toolkit and build your first linkable asset this week.
Start free trial