AI visibility belongs in the marketing mix, but not where many marketers are putting it. That is the argument made by Nick LeRoy in Search Engine Land, in a piece that pushes back against treating AI search as simply another SEO channel. The visibility AI systems give a brand may influence how people think about it, even while the traffic it sends remains uncertain.
AI visibility may influence brand consideration, the piece argues. When an AI assistant names a brand, recommends it or cites it as a source, that mention can shape what a person thinks before they ever visit a website. The effect is closer to brand exposure than to a click: the brand enters the conversation early, at the moment a person is forming an opinion or narrowing a choice.
That framing matters because it changes what success looks like. If the value of AI visibility sits in consideration rather than in visits, then counting clicks will understate it, and optimising only for clicks will miss the point. The brand's presence inside answers is itself the outcome, even when the person reading the answer never follows a link.
At the same time, the traffic value of AI visibility remains uncertain. Being cited or mentioned inside an AI answer does not reliably translate into visits, and the referral traffic that AI systems do send is still small and uneven compared with classic search. Marketers who promise a traffic return from AI visibility work are therefore promising something the evidence does not yet support.
The uncertainty is not a reason to ignore AI visibility, but it is a reason to be honest about what it can deliver. A channel whose main effect is on consideration should be judged on consideration, not on a traffic forecast borrowed from SEO. The piece's caution is aimed at the gap between what AI visibility is sold as and what it can currently be shown to do.
GEO, the work of optimising for generative engines, needs different goals and budgets than traditional SEO, the piece argues. Treating it as an extension of SEO, funded from the same budget and judged by the same metrics, sets it up to fail on measures it was never designed to meet. The goals should reflect what AI visibility actually does: shape consideration, build familiarity and put a brand into the answers people trust.
The budget question follows from the goals. If AI visibility is a brand activity as much as a search activity, then its funding should be judged alongside other brand spending, not squeezed into an SEO budget built around rankings and clicks. That separation also protects SEO itself: when each channel is judged on its own terms, neither is blamed for the other's shortcomings.
For SEOs, the argument is a useful check on how AI work is scoped and sold. Adding AI visibility to an SEO retainer without changing the goals or the measurement invites disappointment, because the work will be judged by rankings and traffic while its real effect sits elsewhere. The honest move is to name the goal up front: if the aim is consideration, say so, and measure it accordingly.
For link builders, the piece points to a similar shift in what counts as a win. A mention inside an AI answer, a citation that puts a brand in front of a person weighing a decision, may matter more than a link that passes authority but is never seen. The work of earning that presence is familiar — useful content, genuine expertise, a reputation worth citing — but the way success is reported needs to catch up with where the visibility actually happens.
Sources: Search Engine Land, November 5, 2026, by Nick LeRoy, on AI visibility in the marketing mix.
Related reading on this site: AI Visibility vs. Rankings: Are Agencies Measuring the Wrong Thing for 2027?, GEO Isn't a Distraction: Referral Data Misses Where AI Shapes Buying, AI Knows What Your Brand Does — But Not Who It's For, Traffic Is Down. Leads Are Up. In-House Teams Rethink AI Search Measurement, ChatGPT Sends 0.62% of Google's Organic Traffic — but Converts at 13.8%, and Reddit Mentions Track AI Visibility at 0.75 — Stronger Than Any Other Signal, Ahrefs Finds.
Linkbaits helps you create content that earns citations and backlinks. Start with the toolkit and build your first linkable asset this week.
Start free trial